CO129-550-7 Rex v. Ng Loi Yuen- appeal to Privy Council 1-1-1934 - 31-12-1934 — Page 125

128

person at the hospital.

-76- 17.

There are two avenues of approach to this side of the

case which have to be explored. Are you satisfied that the

accused was attempting suicide at that moment ? It seemed to me as I listened to Learned Counsel for Accused's excellent

+

speech that it was accepted that the accused had made up his

mind to commit suicide. You will remember that was his

defence, his excuse, his palliation before the Magistrate "I

have no money, therefore I commit suicide."

The other avenue is the letters.

It is a grave matter and it is a matter on which I am obliged to claim your indulgence for a few moments.

You will recollect that this basket which was brought

The three

by the accused to the shop on the 21st June was handed out

of the cockloft in which accused put it, by an employee of the

shop on 23rd and in that basket when it was examined at the

police station, these three letters were found.

letters are written on what I think I may call characteristic

note-paper of which seven other sheets were also found in the

basket.

The Crown ask you to accept on that evidence, remembering

also the dramatic incident when the Magistrate was out of

Court, where the accused having a soiled singlet on and wanting a clean one turned to Inspector o'Donovan and said "Pei ngo" that the accused admits ownership of the basket.

The Crown case is here is a man who was ¤ttmptingx

disappointed and despela te. We know he made up his mind to commit suicide. We go further and we say that he was of that

antisocial turn of mind which gives its adherence to pernicious

doctrines such as these in these letters. The Crown don't say

- "Although the three characters on the letter dated December 1933 and marked 7-C are the three characters representing one of